Case Studies >
Card Sort Study

Substantial Cost Savings & Reduced Call Time for a Top Bank

Information Architecture Research To Improve Customer Service Efficiency

Results

2 Minutes
Average Reduction in Call Handling Time
Arrows relating 2 minutes of average reduction time to 6.2 million dollars in saved operational costs in a quarter
$6.2 Million
Saved in Operational Costs in a Quarter After Release
  • Research Contribution:
  • Card sorting revealed how customer service agents naturally organize information.
  • I analyzed these mental models and delivered clear recommendations for restructuring the Fare Rules interface.
  • These insights directly informed the redesign that reduced agent search time, shortened call duration, and improved operational efficiency.
  • After the Project: As is typical during formative research, this study was followed by a usability test, which yielded additional data and suggested integrating the Fare Rules application with the customer service agent dashboard.


Overview and Abstract

  • Context: Fare Rules, a feature within a larger banking application customer service agents use to determine travel costs.  
  • Problem: The text-based interface made information hard to find, slowing down agents and increasing human error, because commands were manually typed, costing the bank millions in operational costs annually.
  • Role: As the Principal UX Researcher, I led method selection, data collection, and synthesis, and collaborated with product managers, help desk agents, and the design team.
  • Skills Applied: Card sorting, information architecture, R programming, statistical visualization, enterprise UX research, quantifiable ROI measurement, dendrogram analysis, mental model extraction.
  • Impact: Reduced call handling time by an average of 2 minutes per agent that led to 6.2 million dollars in cost efficiency improvements in a quarter. Improved efficiency and usability for customer service agents via a natural categorization structure. These insights directly shaped the new IA and improved customer service agency efficiency.

Project Runway
‍‍


Methods and Process

A flowchart of my research process starting two months before the study and a day by day breakdown during the study
A flowchart of my research process starting two months before the study and a day-by-day breakdown during the study
The group relates to booking and flight details. This group contains number and trip number cards, two fields currently used to search Fare Rules. This grouping shows the design should allow for searches by number and trip number, a design insight.
Finding categories for groups with 3D clustering, conducted with Optimal Workshop. This is group 4, a group talking about booking and flight details..

The Optimal Workshop analysis consolidated 51 fragmented categories into 21, defining four major groups.


Further Analysis in R

This analysis was conducted after the report was released.  Work with the existing tool identified the following needs:
The following is a dendrogram I created, a diagram used to determine which cards should be grouped together:

The dendrogram for the card sort (with R visualizations)
The dendrogram is useful but does not show individual agreement of users on cards for clusters. I needed a heatmap, the diagram seen below:
A heatmap of the amount of participant agreement about two cards in the Fare Rules Card Sort
The following is a snippet from the program that generated both the dendrogram and heatmap:
This shows a loop that I used to create a similarity matrix .


R Analysis Outcome

  • These visualizations revealed natural groupings that weren't obvious from the basic analysis:
  • Ticket types needed to be separated from routing information.
  • Fare calculators belonged with pricing rules rather than with policy information.
  • Agent commands were most effective when grouped by frequency of use.


Other Case Studies

Increased Student Enrollment in Universities
Qualitative Research, Click Data, and Google Analytics Driving Conversion Rate Optimization
Click rate percentages of different buttons in an email template in the study
As Senior Manager of User Research at Nabler, I led a three-person team in a mixed-methods study for a higher-education client. Building on prior data, we pinpointed the best email to send prospective students, increasing enrollment and boosting conversion rates.
View Card Sort Study
Improved UX Research for All Agency Clients
UX Research Democratization Via A Playbook and Classroom Sessions
As the Principal User Researcher at Tallwave, I authored a playbook to disseminate, standardize, and optimize methods across the UX team. Integrated into Community of Practice sessions, it saw widespread adoption, elevating how the team gathered and applied user insights.
View Playbook Project